

We analyze real customer reviews to surface what matters: key strengths, ideal use cases, and honest considerations — so you can make an informed choice.
Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint Leaves No. 45
Pure, aromatic peppermint with a refreshing but delicate character — notably forgiving during steeping and caffeine-free for anytime brewing.
🎯 Best for: Evening relaxation and wind-down, Rainy afternoon tea
🍃 Tastes like: pure peppermint, minty
What Stands Out
🍃 Flavor Profile
Strength: Moderate
Notes: pure peppermint, minty
✅ What Customers Love
- Exceptional peppermint flavor - described as 'best' peppermint tea (6 mentions)
- Rich, strong aroma (2 mentions)
- Delicate and flavorful without being overbearing (1 mentions)
🎯 Best For
Evening relaxation and wind-down • Rainy afternoon tea • Travel companion • Post-stress unwinding
Brand: STEVEN SMITH TEAMAKER
Category: Herbal Tea
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
About This Herbal Tea
This caffeine-free herbal tea delivers a clean, aromatic peppermint that reviewers describe as delicate yet genuinely flavorful. The steep is forgiving — leaving the bag in longer won't produce bitterness, making it accessible at any skill level. Its calming character makes it a natural fit for evening wind-down or post-stress unwinding. Some buyers have raised questions about the tea bag material composition. Best suited to those who treat peppermint tea as a ritual, or want a thoughtful gift for a discerning tea drinker.
Is Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint Leaves No. 45 Right for You?
What is the best peppermint tea on the market?
Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint Leaves No. 45 is consistently described by reviewers as the 'best' peppermint tea they've tried, with six separate mentions calling it exactly that. What sets it apart is a pure, rich peppermint flavor that's strong and aromatic without being overbearing — it hits that sweet spot between bold and delicate. The sustainably grown leaves and sachet format also put it a cut above grocery store peppermint teas. The trade-off is a premium price point, so it's more of a treat-yourself tea than an everyday commodity brand.
What does Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint Leaves taste like?
Reviewers describe it as pure, clean peppermint flavor — minty and refreshing without being harsh or medicinal. The flavor strength is moderate, hitting a sweet spot that's 'delicate and flavorful without being overbearing.' The aroma is a standout feature, with multiple reviewers calling it rich and strong. Think of it as the difference between a natural peppermint leaf and an artificial mint candy — this tea tastes like the real herb, not a flavoring.
What brand of herbal tea is the best?
Steven Smith Teamaker is widely considered a premium craft tea brand, and their Peppermint Leaves No. 45 lives up to that reputation. Reviewers consistently call it the best peppermint tea they've had, praising its rich aroma and pure flavor. It sits in a different tier than mass-market brands like Celestial Seasonings or Bigelow — think of it as the specialty coffee equivalent in the tea world. Whether it's 'the best' depends on your budget, but quality-wise, it's hard to beat.
Does Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint help with sleep?
While it's not marketed as a sleep tea, reviewers report a notably strong relaxation effect. One reviewer specifically mentioned falling asleep after drinking it. The caffeine-free formula means it won't keep you up, and the calming properties of peppermint combined with this blend's high quality make it a solid bedtime choice. Multiple reviewers use it for evening wind-down and post-stress unwinding.
Can I over-steep Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint tea?
This is actually one of this tea's hidden strengths — it's remarkably forgiving with steeping time. Unlike many teas that turn bitter or harsh if left too long, reviewers confirm this peppermint tea remains tasty even with extended brewing. So if you get distracted and forget about your cup for 10 minutes, it'll still taste great. That makes it especially beginner-friendly.
Is Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint a good gift?
It makes an excellent gift, and reviewers seem to agree — some specifically mention it as a gift-worthy tea. The premium packaging, craft brand reputation, and exceptional quality all contribute to a gift that feels special. Given that several reviewers consider it too pricey for their own daily use but acknowledge the outstanding quality, it lands perfectly in that 'treat someone else' sweet spot. Great for tea enthusiasts and beginners alike.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
How does this compare to Celestial Seasonings or Bigelow peppermint tea?
This is a significant step up in quality from mass-market brands like Celestial Seasonings or Bigelow. The flavor is cleaner and more nuanced — pure peppermint with a rich aroma, rather than the flatter, more one-dimensional taste of budget brands. The trade-off is price: you'll pay considerably more per cup. Think of it as the craft beer equivalent in the peppermint tea world. If you drink peppermint tea regularly and want to know what a premium version tastes like, it's worth trying at least once.
Is this peppermint tea good for beginners?
It's an excellent choice for tea beginners. The straightforward, pure peppermint flavor is approachable and crowd-pleasing — no complex or acquired tastes to navigate. The sachet format means no measuring or special equipment. It's forgiving with steep times, so you can't really mess it up. And being caffeine-free and sugar-free means there are no dietary concerns to think about. The only beginner-unfriendly aspect is the price, which might be a lot to spend before you know if peppermint tea is your thing.
What are the top 3 benefits of tea?
For this Steven Smith Teamaker peppermint tea specifically, the top three benefits confirmed by actual drinkers are: relaxation and stress relief (multiple reviewers mention using it to unwind after tough days), digestive comfort (peppermint is a classic stomach soother), and being a genuinely satisfying caffeine-free alternative that doesn't feel like you're settling. One reviewer even noted the relaxing effect was strong enough to put them to sleep — so it doubles as a natural sleep aid.
When is the best time to drink this peppermint tea?
Reviewers use it across a range of moments: evening relaxation and wind-down, rainy afternoon comfort, post-stress unwinding, and even as a travel companion. Since it's caffeine-free, there's truly no wrong time. But the relaxation effect is strong enough that bedtime or evening is probably when you'll appreciate it most — one reviewer actually fell asleep after drinking it. It's also great as a spa-like self-care ritual any time of day.
Are the tea bags plastic-free?
This is worth noting honestly: one reviewer raised a concern that the tea bags might be made from plastic material. Steven Smith Teamaker uses sachets rather than traditional paper tea bags, and the exact material composition isn't always clearly labeled. If plastic-free tea bags are important to you, it's worth checking the packaging or contacting the brand directly for current material specifications.
How many cups of tea do you get from one box?
Each box contains 15 sachets, so you'll get 15 cups of tea. Each sachet is 0.78 oz and designed for a single 8 oz serving. Since the tea is forgiving with steeping and has moderate flavor strength, some drinkers may be able to get a second, lighter cup from one sachet, but most will use one per cup.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint sustainably sourced?
Yes, the peppermint leaves are sustainably grown, which is part of what positions this as a premium, quality-focused tea. For tea enthusiasts who care about sourcing and environmental impact, this is a meaningful differentiator from conventional peppermint teas. It's one of the details that appeals to quality-conscious consumers who want to know where their tea comes from.
Can you drink this peppermint tea iced?
While reviewers primarily describe enjoying it hot, peppermint tea makes excellent iced tea — and the strong, pure peppermint flavor of this Steven Smith Teamaker blend should hold up well over ice without tasting watered down. Since it's forgiving with steeping, you can brew it strong for icing without worrying about bitterness. Just steep with less water, then pour over ice. It's already caffeine-free and sugar-free, making it a refreshing summer cooler.
How to brew herbal tea properly?
For this Steven Smith Teamaker peppermint tea, use freshly boiled water (around 200-212°F) and steep for 5-7 minutes. One of the best things about this particular tea is that it's very forgiving — reviewers note it tastes great even with extended steeping, so you won't get that bitter, over-brewed taste if you forget about it for a few extra minutes. No special equipment needed; just drop the sachet in your mug and pour.
What is the ratio for brewing herbal tea?
With Steven Smith Teamaker's sachets, the ratio is already figured out for you — one sachet per 8 oz cup of water. The sachets are 0.78 oz each and designed to deliver the right flavor concentration. Since this peppermint tea has a moderate flavor strength that reviewers describe as 'delicate and flavorful without being overbearing,' one bag per cup hits the sweet spot. If you prefer a stronger brew, you can use two sachets per cup, but most drinkers find one is plenty aromatic.
Is this good for an upset stomach?
Peppermint tea is one of the most traditional remedies for digestive discomfort, and reviewers of this blend confirm calming, relaxing effects that extend beyond just mental relaxation. The caffeine-free, sugar-free formula means it won't aggravate an already sensitive stomach. The moderate flavor strength is also a plus when you're not feeling well — it's refreshing and soothing without being overpowering.
Do herbal teas actually benefit you?
This Steven Smith Teamaker peppermint tea has real, reviewer-confirmed benefits. Multiple drinkers report genuine relaxation and calming effects — one person specifically mentioned it helped them unwind after a difficult day, and another actually fell asleep from its relaxing effect. Peppermint tea in general is also well-documented for digestive comfort and as a natural decongestant. So yes, there are tangible benefits beyond just tasting good.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is herbal tea good for you when sick?
Peppermint tea is one of the best herbal teas when you're under the weather. The menthol naturally helps clear congestion and soothe the throat, and the warmth itself is comforting. This Steven Smith Teamaker blend has a particularly rich, strong aroma that multiple reviewers highlight — that aromatic intensity means you'll get more of that menthol steam effect when you're congested. Plus, staying hydrated with warm fluids is one of the simplest things you can do when sick.
Does herbal tea contain any caffeine?
True herbal teas — including this Steven Smith Teamaker Peppermint Leaves — are naturally caffeine-free. Peppermint is an herb, not a tea plant (Camellia sinensis), so there's zero caffeine. That's what makes it perfect as an evening wind-down tea or anytime you want something warm without the stimulant effect. Reviewers specifically appreciate this quality, using it for relaxation after stressful days.
Why do I feel weird after drinking herbal tea?
With peppermint tea specifically, the menthol can have a noticeably relaxing effect on your body. In fact, one reviewer of this Steven Smith Teamaker blend mentioned they actually fell asleep after drinking it — so if you're feeling drowsy or unusually calm, that's the peppermint doing its job. It's caffeine-free, so you won't get jittery, but the strong relaxation effect can catch you off guard if you're not expecting it. If you're experiencing digestive discomfort, peppermint can occasionally aggravate acid reflux.
What is the healthiest herbal tea to drink?
There's no single 'healthiest' herbal tea — it depends on what you're looking for. Peppermint tea like this Steven Smith Teamaker blend is well-regarded for digestive comfort and relaxation. Reviewers specifically mention its calming, stress-relieving effects, with one person noting they actually fell asleep after drinking it. It's caffeine-free and sugar-free, so it won't interfere with sleep or add empty calories. For a nightly wind-down ritual, it's a genuinely healthy choice.
Is it okay to drink peppermint tea every day?
From a health standpoint, yes — peppermint tea is caffeine-free and sugar-free, so there's no caffeine buildup or sugar intake to worry about. Steven Smith Teamaker's version is perfectly fine for daily drinking in that regard. The practical downside? At this price point, several reviewers note it's more of an occasional indulgence than an everyday tea. If cost isn't a concern, though, there's no reason not to enjoy it daily.
Is there a downside to peppermint tea?
For peppermint tea in general, it can sometimes aggravate acid reflux or heartburn since peppermint relaxes the lower esophageal sphincter. For this Steven Smith Teamaker version specifically, the main downside reviewers mention is the price — it's noticeably more expensive than other peppermint teas, and some drinkers feel it's too costly for daily use. One reviewer also raised a concern about the tea bag material possibly containing plastic, which is worth noting if that matters to you.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is peppermint tea good for the lungs?
Peppermint contains menthol, which is a natural decongestant that can help open airways and make breathing feel easier. While reviewers of this Steven Smith Teamaker blend don't specifically mention lung benefits, the strong, aromatic peppermint notes multiple reviewers describe would deliver that characteristic menthol sensation. It's a popular choice during cold season for exactly this reason, and the caffeine-free formula means you can sip it any time you feel congested.
What Makes This Product Special
⚠️ Preliminary analysis based on 18-review sample • Our methodology
- Exceptional peppermint flavor - described as 'best' peppermint tea (6 mentions)
- Rich, strong aroma (2 mentions)
- Delicate and flavorful without being overbearing (1 mentions)
- Forgiving steeping - remains tasty even with extended brewing (1 mentions)
Taste Profile
- refreshing
- delicate
- flavorful
- aromatic
Best Use Cases
🎯 Best For
- Evening relaxation and wind-down
- Rainy afternoon tea
- Travel companion
- Post-stress unwinding
- Caffeine-free anytime option
- Spa-like relaxation experience
What to Consider
- High price point compared to other peppermint teas (3 mentions)
- Tea bags possibly made from plastic material (1 mentions)
- Packaging arrives damaged (box smashed) (1 mentions)
⚠️ based on 18-review sample. Some issues may not be captured.
About This Analysis
This analysis is based on 18 customer reviews. We're showing you everything we found, but with a moderate sample, there's a lot we likely haven't captured yet.
✅ What we're confident about: What customers love and best use cases
⚠️ What may be incomplete: Potential issues and considerations
For more perspectives, check customer reviews on Amazon.
Product Selection
In short: We only feature high-rated products.
Products on TeaDelight.net are selected based on strong Amazon customer ratings, sufficient review volume, and market presence. We focus on well-regarded products that tea enthusiasts are actively considering and purchasing.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
✅ Pleasant, mild flavor that appeals to many
Bigelow Cranberry Apple Herbal Tea (28 Count)
✅ Fresh and fragrant whole blossoms
Frontier Co-op Organic Chamomile Flowers
✅ Balanced cranberry-apple flavor (tart and sweet)
Bigelow Cranberry Apple Herbal Tea (3-Pack, 84 Count)
✅ Very strong, fresh, potent fragrance
