

We analyze real customer reviews to surface what matters: key strengths, ideal use cases, and honest considerations — so you can make an informed choice.
Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea K-Cup Pods (6-Pack, 72 Count)
A bold Earl Grey K-cup with assertive bergamot and a full-bodied character that stays consistent cup after cup — without the dilution common in pod formats.
🎯 Best for: daily drinking, all-year consumption
🍃 Tastes like: bergamot, black tea, Earl Grey
🍃 Flavor Profile
Strength: Bold
Notes: bergamot, black tea, Earl Grey
✅ What Customers Love
- Great taste and quality (4 mentions)
- Strong Earl Grey flavor (3 mentions)
- Consistent flavor across batches (2 mentions)
🎯 Best For
daily drinking • all-year consumption • winter warmth • iced tea preparation
Brand: Bigelow Tea
Category: Black Tea
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
About This Black Tea
Bigelow's Earl Grey translates well to the K-cup format, delivering bold bergamot and a full-bodied black tea base that long-time fans recognize from the traditional bagged version. The tea holds its strength in pod form — not watered down, not bitter — making it reliable for daily use year-round. It brews cleanly over ice for an iced Earl Grey, and flavor stays consistent batch to batch. Those seeking the strongest possible black tea base may prefer alternatives, but Keurig users who want dependable, fragrant Earl Grey every morning will find it a natural staple.
Is Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea K-Cup Pods (6-Pack, 72 Count) Right for You?
How does Bigelow Earl Grey taste in K-Cup format compared to regular tea bags?
According to long-time Bigelow drinkers, the K-Cup version is an accurate reproduction of their traditional steeped bag version. Reviewers specifically note that it doesn't water down the tea the way many K-Cup teas do — you still get that full-bodied, strong bergamot flavor that Bigelow Earl Grey is known for. Some fans with 40+ years of brand loyalty confirm it holds up well in the Keurig format.
What does Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cup tea taste like?
Reviewers describe it as bold and full-bodied with a strong bergamot (citrusy, floral) aroma that defines classic Earl Grey. The flavor is consistent and flavorful without being watered down — a common complaint with K-Cup teas that Bigelow manages to avoid. You get distinct black tea and bergamot notes in every cup, with no bitter aftertaste. If you like a tea that has character and aroma rather than just 'hot brown water,' this delivers.
How does Bigelow Earl Grey compare to Twinings Earl Grey K-Cups?
This is one of the most common comparisons for Earl Grey fans. Bigelow tends to have a stronger bergamot flavor and a full-bodied cup, while Twinings is sometimes noted for having a slightly stronger black tea base. One reviewer mentioned that Bigelow has a weaker black tea flavor compared to Twinings, but multiple others praised Bigelow's strong Earl Grey flavor and bold overall taste. Price-wise, the 72-count Bigelow pack has historically been about 20% cheaper than Twinings, though pricing has become more similar recently. If you prioritize bergamot punch and consistency, Bigelow has the edge.
Who should NOT buy Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups?
If you're looking for the absolute strongest black tea base possible, this might not be your cup (pun intended). One reviewer noted it has a weaker black tea flavor compared to competitors like Twinings. It's also not ideal if you prefer loose leaf tea and want maximum control over your brew strength. And if you don't own a Keurig, obviously these won't work for you — Bigelow sells the same Earl Grey in regular tea bags. But for the vast majority of K-Cup tea drinkers, this is a top-tier choice.
How long has Bigelow been making Earl Grey tea?
Bigelow is a family-owned tea company that's been around since 1945. Reviewers mention brand loyalty spanning over 40 years, which speaks to the consistency and quality they've maintained. The fact that long-time fans confirm the K-Cup version tastes just like the original steeped bag version is a testament to how seriously Bigelow takes their recipes — they didn't cut corners when adapting to the K-Cup format.
Is Bigelow Earl Grey good for beginners who are new to tea?
Yes, this is an excellent choice for tea beginners. The K-Cup format eliminates all the guesswork around water temperature, steeping time, and tea-to-water ratio — you just pop in a pod and press a button. The flavor is consistent across batches, so you know exactly what to expect every time. Bigelow is a widely available, reliable brand, and Earl Grey's bergamot flavor makes it more interesting than plain black tea without being overwhelming. Reviewers confirm there's no bitter aftertaste, which is a common concern for new tea drinkers.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
What is the best way to brew black tea?
For these Bigelow K-Cup pods, the brewing is handled by your Keurig — just pop in a pod and select your cup size. For the boldest flavor, use the smallest cup setting (6 oz) since reviewers note the strong, full-bodied taste is one of this tea's best qualities. If you prefer a lighter cup, the 8 oz setting works well too. One reviewer tip: you can use the iced coffee function on newer Keurig models to brew a concentrated cup over ice for iced Earl Grey.
What are common black tea mistakes?
The most common mistake with black tea is using water that isn't hot enough — black tea needs a full rolling boil (around 212°F). With Bigelow K-Cup pods, your Keurig handles the temperature for you, which eliminates that problem entirely. Another common mistake is over-steeping, which causes bitterness. Again, the K-Cup format avoids this since the water passes through the pod in a controlled way. Reviewers specifically note these pods have no bitter aftertaste, which suggests Bigelow has dialed in the grind and volume to prevent over-extraction.
How to brew black tea for iced tea?
These Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups work surprisingly well for iced tea. Reviewers mention using the iced coffee function on their Keurig, which brews a more concentrated cup directly over ice. If your machine doesn't have that function, brew on the smallest cup size (6 oz) into a mug, then pour over a full glass of ice. The bold bergamot flavor holds up well when diluted by ice — it makes a refreshing iced Earl Grey that reviewers say they enjoy year-round.
Can you make iced Earl Grey with Bigelow K-Cups?
Yes, and reviewers specifically mention this as an unexpected benefit. If your Keurig has an iced coffee function, use that to brew a concentrated cup directly over ice. If not, brew on the smallest cup size (6 oz) and pour over a full glass of ice. The bold bergamot flavor is strong enough to hold up to dilution from the ice. Reviewers say they enjoy these pods year-round, switching between hot in winter and iced in warmer months.
Do these Bigelow K-Cups work in all Keurig machines?
These are standard Keurig K-Cup pods, so they're compatible with all Keurig K-Cup brewers (including the classic, plus, elite, and newer models). One reviewer did mention experiencing a defective pod that melted in their machine, but this appears to be a rare manufacturing issue rather than a compatibility problem. The vast majority of reviews confirm they work perfectly in their Keurig machines.
What is the best cup size setting for Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups?
For the boldest, most flavorful cup, use the 6 oz setting on your Keurig. Reviewers praise the strong, full-bodied flavor, and the smaller cup size keeps that concentration high. The 8 oz setting still produces a good cup, but if you go to 10 or 12 oz, you'll start to dilute the flavor. For iced tea, brew at 6 oz over ice — the ice melt will bring it up to a normal serving size while keeping the bergamot punch.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is black tea actually healthy?
Yes, black tea is widely recognized for its health benefits. It's rich in antioxidants (particularly theaflavins and thearubigins), supports heart health, and provides a moderate caffeine boost without the jitters many people get from coffee. Bigelow Earl Grey adds bergamot oil, which has its own antioxidant properties. The key is consistent daily consumption — and that's where these K-Cup pods shine. Reviewers describe them as a year-round daily staple, making it easy to build that healthy tea habit.
What happens if we drink black tea daily?
Daily black tea consumption is associated with improved heart health, better gut health, and a steady supply of antioxidants. The moderate caffeine provides consistent energy without the spikes and crashes of coffee. Reviewers of these Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups describe them as a daily drinking staple and a regular reorder item, with some fans drinking Bigelow for over 40 years — which is a pretty solid long-term endorsement. As with any caffeinated drink, just be mindful of your total daily intake.
What are 5 benefits of drinking black tea?
Five key benefits: (1) Heart health support from antioxidants called theaflavins. (2) Moderate, steady caffeine for alertness without jitters. (3) Improved gut health from polyphenols that feed beneficial bacteria. (4) Mental focus — L-theanine in tea promotes calm concentration. (5) Hydration — despite the caffeine, tea is still a net hydrator. With these Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups, you also get the added benefit of bergamot oil, which has its own antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. And the K-Cup convenience means you're more likely to actually drink it daily.
Is black tea good for you in the morning?
Absolutely. Black tea is a great morning drink — you get a moderate caffeine kick (40-70 mg vs coffee's 95-200 mg) plus L-theanine for calm, focused energy. Many reviewers use these Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups as their daily morning ritual. The K-Cup format means your tea is ready in about a minute, which is perfect for busy mornings. If you find coffee too intense or acidic first thing, Earl Grey is a flavorful, gentler alternative that still wakes you up.
How to make black tea more tasty?
Bigelow Earl Grey already has a lot going on flavor-wise — the bergamot gives it a distinctive citrusy, aromatic quality that reviewers describe as bold and flavorful. But if you want to dress it up, try adding a splash of milk and honey for a London Fog-style drink, or a squeeze of lemon to brighten the bergamot notes. For iced versions, a little simple syrup goes a long way. The strong base flavor of these pods means additions complement rather than mask the tea.
What is the number one black tea in the world?
That depends on what you're looking for. Bigelow Earl Grey is one of the most popular black teas in the United States, and their K-Cup pods make it one of the most convenient options for daily drinkers. Reviewers praise its consistent flavor across batches and bold bergamot taste. While tea connoisseurs might point to single-origin Darjeeling or Assam teas as 'the best,' for an everyday black tea that delivers reliably every single cup, Bigelow Earl Grey is a strong contender — especially in K-Cup format where consistency really matters.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is black tea good for you when sick?
Black tea can be comforting when you're under the weather. The warm liquid soothes the throat, the caffeine can help with headaches and fatigue, and the antioxidants support your immune system. Bergamot oil in Earl Grey also has mild antibacterial properties. Reviewers mention these Bigelow K-Cups as a winter warmth staple, and the K-Cup format is especially convenient when you're feeling too rough to fuss with loose leaf or tea bags — just pop in a pod.
Which is healthier, black tea or green tea?
Both are healthy — they come from the same plant (Camellia sinensis) and share many benefits. Green tea gets more headlines for its EGCG antioxidants, but black tea has its own powerful antioxidants (theaflavins) that support heart health and may help with cholesterol. The best tea for your health is honestly the one you'll drink consistently. If you prefer the bold, aromatic flavor of Earl Grey over the grassier taste of green tea, these Bigelow K-Cups make it effortless to build a daily habit.
What is the healthiest brand of tea?
There's no single 'healthiest brand' — the health benefits of tea come from the tea leaves themselves, not the brand name. What matters most is drinking quality tea consistently. Bigelow uses natural bergamot flavoring in their Earl Grey and has maintained their quality for decades. The K-Cup format makes daily consumption effortless, and reviewers describe it as a satisfying daily tea they reorder regularly. Consistency of habit matters more than chasing the 'healthiest' label.
How to brew black tea with tea bags?
If you're using traditional Bigelow Earl Grey tea bags (not K-Cups), bring fresh water to a full rolling boil (212°F), pour it over the tea bag, and steep for 3-5 minutes depending on how strong you like it. But if you own a Keurig, the K-Cup version handles all of this automatically — just insert the pod, select your cup size, and you get a consistent cup every time. Reviewers specifically praise the K-Cup version for reproducing the same flavor as the traditional steeped bag.
What is the healthiest form of black tea?
Loose leaf black tea is generally considered the healthiest form since it tends to contain larger, less processed leaves with more intact antioxidants. That said, Bigelow's K-Cup pods still deliver the core benefits of black tea — antioxidants, moderate caffeine, and polyphenols. The convenience factor matters too: if K-Cups mean you actually drink tea consistently instead of skipping it, that daily habit adds up. Reviewers describe these pods as a satisfying daily tea they reorder regularly, which suggests the health benefits compound over time.
Is there enough caffeine in black tea to keep you awake?
Black tea has moderate caffeine — enough to keep you alert and focused, but less than coffee. These Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups provide a gentle boost that works well for mornings and early afternoons. If you're sensitive to caffeine, you might want to avoid drinking them in the evening. Reviewers use these as their daily go-to tea, which suggests the caffeine level is comfortable for regular consumption without causing sleep issues when consumed at reasonable hours.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is black tea more caffeine than coffee?
No — coffee typically has significantly more caffeine than black tea. A standard cup of coffee has roughly 95-200 mg of caffeine, while a cup of black tea generally has 40-70 mg. These Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cup pods will give you a moderate caffeine boost that's enough to be alert without the intensity of coffee. Many reviewers use them as their daily morning or afternoon drink, suggesting the caffeine level hits a nice sweet spot — energizing but not overstimulating.
Which tea is highest in caffeine?
Among common tea types, black tea (like this Bigelow Earl Grey) tends to have the most caffeine, followed by oolong, green, and white tea. Within black teas, caffeine levels vary by processing and brew time. Since K-Cup pods have a fixed brew time controlled by the machine, you'll get a consistent caffeine level with every cup — typically in the 40-70 mg range for black tea pods. That's enough for a solid morning pick-me-up without approaching coffee-level intensity.
How much caffeine in black tea vs coffee?
A cup of black tea typically has 40-70 mg of caffeine, while coffee runs 95-200 mg. So you're looking at roughly half to a third of the caffeine with these Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups compared to a coffee K-Cup. That makes them a great option if you want to cut back on caffeine without going cold turkey, or if you want an afternoon drink that won't keep you up at night. The L-theanine naturally present in tea also provides a smoother, calmer alertness compared to coffee.
Is black tea good for weight loss?
Black tea can support weight management as part of a healthy diet. It's essentially calorie-free (without added sugar or milk), contains caffeine that can mildly boost metabolism, and its polyphenols may help with fat metabolism. These Bigelow Earl Grey K-Cups are a great swap for sugary drinks or calorie-heavy coffee shop beverages. Just keep in mind that tea alone isn't a magic weight loss solution — it works best alongside a balanced diet and regular activity.
What Customers Love
⚠️ Limited sample based on limited customer feedback (9 reviews) • Our methodology
- Great taste and quality (4 mentions)
- Strong Earl Grey flavor (3 mentions)
- Consistent flavor across batches (2 mentions)
- Full-bodied taste (2 mentions)
- Does not water down tea in K-cup format (1 mentions)
- No bitter aftertaste (1 mentions)
Taste Profile
- full-bodied
- strong
- consistent
- flavorful
- not watered down
- not bitter
Best Use Cases
🎯 Best For
- daily drinking
- all-year consumption
- winter warmth
- iced tea preparation
- regular reorder staple
- Keurig machine convenience
⚠️ Not Ideal For
- users seeking strongest possible black tea base
What to Consider
- Weaker black tea flavor compared to competitors (Twinings) (1 mentions)
- K-cups melt in machine (defective pods) (1 mentions)
⚠️ Important: This analysis is based on limited customer feedback (9 reviews). We've shared what we found, but there may be additional considerations we haven't captured.
About This Analysis
This analysis is based on 9 customer reviews. We're showing you everything we found, but with a small sample, there's a lot we likely haven't captured yet.
✅ What we're confident about: What customers love and best use cases
⚠️ What may be incomplete: Potential issues and considerations
For more perspectives, check customer reviews on Amazon.
Product Selection
In short: We only feature high-rated products.
Products on TeaDelight.net are selected based on strong Amazon customer ratings, sufficient review volume, and market presence. We focus on well-regarded products that tea enthusiasts are actively considering and purchasing.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
✅ Authentic restaurant-quality taste
Tea Zone Thai Tea Leaves
✅ Strong, authentic cinnamon flavor
Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Spice Black Tea
✅ Strong, authentic lychee aroma and flavor
Golden Sail Lychee Black Tea
✅ Non-bitter taste even with longer steeping
