

We analyze real customer reviews to surface what matters: key strengths, ideal use cases, and honest considerations — so you can make an informed choice.
Bigelow Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea
A decaffeinated Earl Grey that preserves bergamot's citrus lift and smooth, aromatic character — the full classic flavor, available any time of day.
🎯 Best for: Morning coffee replacement, Evening relaxation
🍃 Tastes like: bergamot, citrus, warm spices
What Stands Out
🍃 Flavor Profile
Strength: Moderate
Notes: bergamot, citrus, warm spices
✅ What Customers Love
- Retains full flavor despite being decaf (5 mentions)
- Strong aroma (4 mentions)
- Individually wrapped tea bags (3 mentions)
🎯 Best For
Morning coffee replacement • Evening relaxation • Afternoon tea break • Daily routine beverage
Brand: Bigelow Tea
Category: Black Tea
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
About This Black Tea
This decaf Earl Grey delivers a moderately bold black tea brightened by citrus bergamot and warm spice notes — cinnamon, cardamom, and light vanilla — with no bitterness or aftertaste. The aroma is notably strong for a decaf, and the smooth finish holds up even lukewarm. Reviewers prize it as an evening staple that doesn't sacrifice the classic Earl Grey complexity they expect. A small number of batches have been reported with an off-putting odor. Best for caffeine-sensitive drinkers and anyone wanting a genuine Earl Grey experience without disrupting sleep.
Is Bigelow Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea Right for You?
Is Bigelow Earl Grey Black Tea decaffeinated?
Yes, this specific Bigelow Earl Grey is fully decaffeinated. What makes it stand out is that reviewers consistently say it retains the full Earl Grey flavor despite being decaf — the bergamot aroma and citrus notes come through strong. It's one of the more common compliments in reviews, with multiple people surprised that a decaf version could taste this close to the real thing.
What does Bigelow decaf Earl Grey taste like?
Reviewers describe a smooth, moderate-strength black tea with prominent bergamot and citrus notes, plus subtle hints of warm spices and light vanilla. The aroma is strong — multiple reviewers specifically call out the fragrance as a highlight. What surprises most people is the lack of that typical 'decaf' taste — there's no aftertaste, and the flavor is rich enough that many can't tell it's decaffeinated. It's not as bold as a full-caffeine Assam, but it's far from weak.
Can you taste the difference between Bigelow's regular and decaf Earl Grey?
According to reviewers, barely. The most common surprise in reviews is how close this decaf version tastes to regular Earl Grey. Five different reviewers specifically mentioned that it retains the full flavor despite being decaffeinated. The bergamot aroma is strong, the taste is smooth, and there's no unpleasant aftertaste that sometimes comes with decaf teas. A very small number of reviewers found the decaf version slightly weaker, but that's the minority opinion.
Is decaf Earl Grey actually decaf?
It's important to know that 'decaf' doesn't mean completely zero caffeine — most decaffeination processes remove about 97-98% of the caffeine, leaving trace amounts (typically 2-5mg per cup versus 40-70mg in regular black tea). That said, Bigelow's decaf Earl Grey is decaf enough that reviewers specifically drink it in the evening without sleep disruption, and caffeine-sensitive individuals report no issues. If you're avoiding caffeine for medical reasons, check with your doctor about those trace amounts.
Is Bigelow decaf Earl Grey a good coffee replacement?
It's one of the most recommended uses for this tea in reviews. Multiple reviewers specifically say it works better than coffee for their morning routine — it's gentler on the stomach, requires less sweetener, and gives you a satisfying warm beverage ritual without caffeine dependency. You won't get the energy boost of coffee, obviously, but if you're trying to cut caffeine while keeping that comforting morning cup habit, reviewers are pretty emphatic that this does the job well.
Can I drink Bigelow decaf Earl Grey before bed?
Yes — this is one of the most popular use cases. With only trace caffeine remaining after decaffeination, reviewers drink it specifically as an evening relaxation tea. Multiple people confirm it doesn't disrupt their sleep. The warm, smooth bergamot flavor is actually quite calming as a bedtime ritual. If you're extremely caffeine-sensitive, you might want to have your last cup an hour before bed rather than right at bedtime, but most reviewers report zero issues.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is black tea good for you in the morning?
Absolutely, and this decaf version is especially interesting for mornings. Multiple reviewers actually use this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey as their morning coffee replacement — they find it gives them a satisfying, warm morning ritual without the caffeine jitters or afternoon crash. It's robust enough to feel like a 'real' morning drink, not watered-down. If you're trying to cut caffeine but miss having a warm, flavorful beverage to start your day, this is exactly what reviewers recommend it for.
How many tea bags come in the Bigelow decaf Earl Grey pack?
You get 120 tea bags total — it's a pack of 6 boxes with 20 tea bags each. Each bag is individually wrapped in a foil pouch, which keeps them fresh and makes them portable. At 120 bags, if you drink one cup a day, that's four months of tea. If you're a two-cup-a-day person, that's still two months. The bulk pack is where the value comes in, especially with Subscribe & Save.
Does Bigelow decaf Earl Grey have an aftertaste?
No — and that's actually one of its standout qualities. Multiple reviewers specifically mention the clean, no-aftertaste finish as a reason they prefer this over other decaf teas. Decaffeinated teas can sometimes leave a flat or slightly chemical taste, but this Bigelow version avoids that. The finish is smooth with lingering bergamot, not that stale 'decaf' sensation you might expect.
Who should NOT buy Bigelow decaf Earl Grey?
Skip this if you're looking for a caffeine boost — it's decaf, so it won't wake you up. It's also not for you if you prefer very strong, bold black teas — the flavor is moderate, not intense. And in fairness, a small number of reviewers reported an off smell in certain batches (described as fishy), which made the tea undrinkable for them. That appears to be a rare quality control issue rather than the norm, but it's worth knowing. If you need your tea to pack a serious punch flavor-wise, you might want regular Earl Grey instead.
What are 5 benefits of drinking black tea?
For this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey specifically, reviewers and research point to: 1) It works as a satisfying coffee replacement — multiple reviewers say it's better than coffee for their morning routine. 2) It's gentle on the stomach, unlike coffee. 3) The decaf formulation supports evening relaxation without disrupting sleep. 4) Reviewers report it soothes the throat. 5) It requires less sweetener than coffee, so you reduce sugar intake. Beyond these, black tea in general supports heart health and provides antioxidants.
How to make black tea more tasty?
This Bigelow decaf Earl Grey is already quite flavorful on its own — reviewers praise its strong bergamot aroma and smooth taste. But if you want to enhance it: a splash of milk rounds out the flavor beautifully with Earl Grey, honey complements the citrus-bergamot notes, and a thin lemon slice doubles down on the citrus. One unexpected tip from the flavor profile — this tea has subtle warm spice and light vanilla notes, so a tiny pinch of cinnamon or a drop of vanilla extract can bring those out.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Is Bigelow decaf Earl Grey good for beginners?
It's actually one of the best beginner teas you can pick. The individually wrapped tea bags mean zero guesswork — no measuring loose leaf, no special equipment. The flavor is consistent every time, and it's forgiving enough that even if your water isn't perfect temperature or you steep it a bit too long, it still tastes good. One reviewer even noted it tastes fine lukewarm. Earl Grey's bergamot flavor is also a great introduction to 'real' tea for people coming from coffee or flavored beverages.
How to brew black tea for iced tea?
This Bigelow decaf Earl Grey actually makes a nice iced tea, especially if you like citrusy, aromatic iced drinks. Brew it double-strength — use two tea bags per cup of hot water, steep for 4-5 minutes, then pour over a full glass of ice. The bergamot and citrus notes shine when cold. Since it's decaf, you can sip it all afternoon without worrying about caffeine. Add a squeeze of lemon to amplify the citrus notes, or a touch of honey before you ice it.
What is the best way to brew black tea?
For this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey specifically, use freshly boiled water (around 200-212°F) and steep for 3-4 minutes. Since each tea bag is individually wrapped, you're getting a consistent, fresh flavor every time. Reviewers note this tea has a smooth, moderate strength that's forgiving — one person even mentioned it tastes good lukewarm, so you don't need to worry about drinking it at the perfect temperature. If you like it stronger, steep a bit longer, but avoid going past 5 minutes to prevent bitterness.
Is there enough caffeine in black tea to keep you awake?
Regular black tea can keep some people awake, but this is a decaf version with only trace caffeine (around 2-5mg per cup). Reviewers specifically drink this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey as an evening relaxation tea and report no sleep disruption. That's actually one of the top reasons people buy it — they want a proper Earl Grey experience at night without lying awake afterward.
Is black tea good for you when sick?
Black tea can be comforting when you're under the weather, and this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey has a specific advantage — reviewers mention it soothes the throat. The warm liquid helps with congestion, the bergamot has mild antimicrobial properties, and since it's decaf, it won't dehydrate you the way caffeinated drinks can. Add honey and lemon for extra throat-soothing power. It's not a medicine, but it's a genuinely comforting sick-day drink.
How to make black tea step by step?
Here's how to make a perfect cup of this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey: 1) Boil fresh water — don't reboil old water, it tastes flat. 2) Open one individually wrapped tea bag. 3) Place it in your cup and pour the hot water over it. 4) Steep for 3-4 minutes. 5) Remove the tea bag. 6) Add milk, honey, or lemon if you like — though many reviewers enjoy this one plain because of its smooth taste and no aftertaste. That's it. No special equipment needed, which is what makes tea bags so beginner-friendly.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
What are common black tea mistakes?
The biggest mistake is using water that's not hot enough — black tea needs near-boiling water to release its full flavor. Over-steeping is another common one, which causes bitterness from excess tannins. With this Bigelow decaf Earl Grey, stick to 3-4 minutes and you'll get that smooth, bergamot-rich flavor without bitterness. Another mistake: squeezing the tea bag when you remove it, which releases bitter compounds. And don't store tea near strong-smelling foods — the individually wrapped bags in this pack help prevent that.
How to brew black tea with tea bags?
With Bigelow's individually wrapped decaf Earl Grey bags, it's simple: Boil fresh water, open one foil packet, place the bag in your mug, pour the hot water directly over it, and steep for 3-4 minutes. Remove the bag — don't squeeze it, as that releases bitter tannins. The individually wrapped bags mean each one is as fresh as the first. You'll notice the bergamot aroma the moment you open the foil packet, which is part of the experience.
How long do you boil black tea for?
You don't actually boil the tea itself — you boil the water, then pour it over the tea bag and steep. For Bigelow's decaf Earl Grey, 3-4 minutes of steeping is the sweet spot. This gives you that smooth, bergamot-forward flavor without pulling out harsh tannins. The tea has a moderate flavor strength, so if you prefer a lighter cup, 2-3 minutes works. If you want more body, push it to 4-5 minutes. The individually wrapped bags keep each one fresh, so you get consistent results every time.
What happens if we drink black tea daily?
Drinking black tea daily is associated with heart health benefits, improved gut health, and antioxidant intake. Since this is Bigelow's decaf version, you get those benefits without daily caffeine accumulation — which is why many reviewers have made it part of their daily routine. Some drink it every morning as a coffee replacement, others use it as an afternoon ritual or evening wind-down. The key advantage of a decaf daily tea is that you can have multiple cups without overstimulation.
Is decaffeinated Earl Grey tea good for you?
Decaf Earl Grey still contains the antioxidants found in black tea, just without the caffeine. Bigelow's decaf version is particularly popular with people who've switched from coffee — reviewers mention it's gentler on the stomach than coffee, soothes the throat, and requires less sweetener. The bergamot oil in Earl Grey also has its own mild calming properties. You lose the caffeine boost, but you keep most of the other benefits of black tea.
Is decaffeinated black tea still healthy?
Decaf black tea retains most of the polyphenols and antioxidants that make black tea beneficial — the decaffeination process removes caffeine but doesn't strip away all the good stuff. With Bigelow's decaf Earl Grey specifically, reviewers report real-world benefits like better sleep (they can drink it in the evening without disruption), reduced coffee dependence, and it being gentler on sensitive stomachs. So yes, you're still getting health benefits, just minus the caffeine.
Customer-Validated Strengths
based on 30-review analysis • Our methodology
- Retains full flavor despite being decaf (5 mentions)
- Strong aroma (4 mentions)
- Individually wrapped tea bags (3 mentions)
- Smooth taste (3 mentions)
- No aftertaste (2 mentions)
- Good value/price with Subscribe & Save (2 mentions)
- Tastes good even when lukewarm (1 mentions)
Taste Profile
- smooth
- strong
- robust
- rich
- no aftertaste
- aromatic
- flavorful
- light vanilla notes
Best Use Cases
🎯 Best For
- Morning coffee replacement
- Evening relaxation
- Afternoon tea break
- Daily routine beverage
- Throat soothing
- Caffeine-sensitive individuals
- Portable tea option (individually wrapped)
⚠️ Not Ideal For
- Those needing strong caffeine
- Users who experienced fishy odor batch
What to Consider
- Fishy smell/odor making it undrinkable (1 mentions)
- Damaged/crushed packaging in shipping (5 mentions)
- Missing boxes from multi-pack orders (2 mentions)
- Smaller tea bags than expected (1 mentions)
- Weak flavor in decaf version (1 mentions)
- Price considered high/indulgent (2 mentions)
based on 30-review sample.
About This Analysis
This analysis is based on 30 customer reviews. We're showing you everything we found, but with our analysis, there's always more to discover.
✅ What we're confident about: What customers love and best use cases
⚠️ What may be incomplete: Potential issues and considerations
For more perspectives, check customer reviews on Amazon.
Product Selection
In short: We only feature high-rated products.
Products on TeaDelight.net are selected based on strong Amazon customer ratings, sufficient review volume, and market presence. We focus on well-regarded products that tea enthusiasts are actively considering and purchasing.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
You Might Also Like
✅ Authentic restaurant-quality taste
Tea Zone Thai Tea Leaves
✅ Strong, authentic cinnamon flavor
Harney & Sons Hot Cinnamon Spice Black Tea
✅ Strong, authentic lychee aroma and flavor
Golden Sail Lychee Black Tea
✅ Non-bitter taste even with longer steeping
